Masculine Stereovision

This article about male roles on television was linked to me earlier. It's pretty old by now, but a good read on its own, and highly insightful. It shocked me a bit—not because I was surprised to see my gender being portrayed this way on TV, but because I've been watching these shows for years and never really noticing. Something's bothered me about them on some level, sure, but this is the first time I've really thought about it... and suddenly it seems outrageously clear.

Now let's not object that “they're only sitcoms”—comedy shows are some of the most popular shows, and we are influenced by their content, perhaps moreso than the more serious shows out there. It might even be argued that the comedic nature of these shows allows us to laugh on the surface, and spare ourselves having to think about what we're seeing, instead simply incorporating it into the complex cauldron of ideas we call our opinions.

But, mostly, I was shocked because I realized I'd bought into the whole scam. A rather large part of me really was thinking of women as more caring and clever, and men in general as clumsy and oafish, even though I also knew full well that many weren't—self included. It makes me a little angry, in fact, and it makes me wonder just how this happened.

At any rate, people... please read and think about it. Talking about men's rights has been a pretty taboo topic, but I think it's time to start paying more attention to it. We have suffered to, and still do—we are far from equal, but this isn't a one-sided issue and the scales are beginning to tip over to the other side now, in some aspects of society. Let's try to stop it before it does so completely.

Comments

1
Mom On September 14 2007 (September 14 2007 01:28)

It is quite odd to me, why the tv companys want to present men as less intelligent, when it is obvious it is the opposite "rule" in the society elswere? What is the point?

2
jolle On September 14 2007 (September 14 2007 07:25)

Some thoughts ...

- The ads depicted in the article are really stupid.

- Of the sitcoms mentioned, I've only really watched (and enjoyed) The Simpsons, and I don't think The Simpsons is a great example. On the surface it maybe seem so, sure, but it really makes fun of everything, and shows the stupid sides of everyone.

- If we are to believe the research on male and female intelligence, there's more 'dumber' males than females, but also more 'smarter' males than females (that is, mean is about the same, but males have higher variance). So a 'dumb' male may be more believable than a 'dumb' female, and thus work better in sitcoms based on 'dumbness'.

- I really need to cut down on 's.

- Didn't someone say that white straight men are the only group that it's politically correct nowadays to make fun of? Hmm... maybe it was me. Doesn't matter. Point is, in for example ads, that doesn't leave much of an option if they really must make fun of some group.

3
Elver On September 14 2007 (September 14 2007 11:07)

This is relevant: http://complicationsensue.blogspot.com/2007/09/oh-humanity.html

Add comment

Markdown may be used.
You may enter a name for yourself. If left blank, the comment will be signed “Anonymous.”
Optionally, you may enter an URL to appear alongside your name.
Enter the word shown in the picture above.